If you think Old Westbury, New York is all about sprawling estates and stately mansions, think again! Nestled within North Hempstead, Old Westbury has quietly developed a sophisticated food scene that’s equal parts elegant and inviting. Whether you’re a local resident, college student, or weekend explorer, there’s a culinary adventure waiting right here on Long Island’s Gold Coast. From refined restaurants to tucked-away bakeries and unexpected food trucks, discover where to eat in Old Westbury like a true insider!
Fine Dining Destinations: Where Elegance Meets Flavor
Old Westbury is synonymous with luxury, and its dining options don’t disappoint when it comes to upscale experiences.
- Old Westbury Golf & Country Club Restaurant (270 Wheatley Road)
Even if you’re not a club member, you might be lucky enough to attend a special event or wedding at this storied venue. The elegant dining room here serves contemporary American and classic continental cuisine—think perfectly grilled steaks, crab cakes, and creative farm-to-table dishes. The view over the rolling fairways creates an unforgettable backdrop, making any meal here feel special.
- Inn at Fox Hollow’s Volpe Restaurant (7755 Jericho Turnpike, just east of Old Westbury border)
While technically in Woodbury, Volpe Restaurant is a local favorite for special occasions. This Italian-inspired eatery is known for its handmade pastas, fresh seafood, and decadent desserts. Pricey, yes, but the polished ambiance and impeccable service make it worth treating yourself.
Cozy Cafés and Breakfast Havens
When it’s time for a casual brunch or a mid-morning pick-me-up, Old Westbury’s café scene has you covered.
- Old Westbury Diner (10 Glen Cove Road)
No friendlier spot in the neighborhood than this classic diner, perfect for a stack of pancakes, a Greek omelet, or a burger and fries just the way you like it. Prices are reasonable (most meals $8–$20), portions are generous, and the vibe is always upbeat. Saturday and Sunday mornings are especially lively!
- Nestlé Toll House Café (Broadway Commons, just a short drive south in Hicksville)
If you’re craving something sweet with your cappuccino, head here for gooey cookies, brownies, and frothy espresso drinks. It’s consistently busy with locals and Westbury college students during finals week!
Bakeries and Sweet Stops: Treat Yourself
While Old Westbury doesn’t overflow with old-school bakeries, several nearby spots are worth the short trek for top-notch sweets.
- Buttercooky Bakery (495 New York Ave, Huntington)
This beloved bakery is about a 15-minute drive but totally worth the trip for exquisite pastries, fluffy cakes, and stunning custom desserts. Try their cannoli, princess cake, or rainbow cookies—the kind of treats that locals order for family celebrations.
- Carle Place Bake Shop (483 Westbury Ave, Carle Place)
Just south of Old Westbury, this hidden gem specializes in cookies, cupcakes, and rustic fruit tarts. Their chocolate rugelach is legendary, providing a sweet taste of Long Island tradition.
Global Eats: Flavors From Around the World
Old Westbury and its neighboring communities feature a selection of globe-trotting cuisine—from sushi to Mediterranean delights.
- Sushi Ya (80 Glen Cove Road, Greenvale Shopping Center)
A five-minute drive north, Sushi Ya is a sushi lover’s paradise. The chirashi bowls brim with freshness and flavor, the sake selection is robust, and the creative rolls keep regulars coming back. Prices range from $18–$45 depending on how elaborate you go.
- Nassau Kosher Grill (125 Post Ave, Westbury)
A favorite for Middle Eastern eats, Nassau Kosher Grill delivers juicy shawarma, crispy falafel, and generous mezze platters. Everything is made with care, and prices stay affordable ($10–$22 per plate). Don’t skip their fluffy pita bread.
Hidden Gems and Unexpected Finds
This is where Old Westbury’s food scene gets fun—less obvious, but so satisfying!
- Gold Coast Food Truck (various locations near LIU Post Campus)
Ask any student or local along Northern Boulevard about the Gold Coast Food Truck and you’ll get knowing smiles. This roaming truck serves up creative twists on classic sandwiches—like Korean beef cheesesteaks and fiery chicken wraps. It’s popular for quick, budget-friendly lunches ($8–$14) and regularly parks at the intersection of Northern Blvd and Post Road.
- Moe’s Gourmet Market (65 Glen Cove Road)
This gourmet market and deli is something of a local secret for weekday lunches and take-home dinners. From hearty eggplant parm heroes to buttery croissants (baked fresh daily), Moe’s rotates their menu with the seasons and always adds a creative spin to comfort classics.
Local Foodie Traditions and Events
Community and cuisine go hand-in-hand in Old Westbury—the neighborhood loves a seasonal food festival or community day!
- Old Westbury Gardens Food Festivals
Every spring and fall, the famous Old Westbury Gardens hosts themed food festivals where visitors picnic on manicured lawns and sample local fare from food trucks, caterers, and artisan vendors. It’s a family-friendly celebration of what makes Long Island’s culinary scene so vibrant.
- Farmers’ Markets (Mineola Blvd at Jericho Turnpike, nearby in Mineola)
Local produce, handmade jams, and farm-fresh eggs are the stars here. Stock up on locally sourced delights and chat with growers who supply many of the area’s top restaurants.
Street Clusters and Favorite Intersections
The food scene naturally clusters near Northern Blvd (Route 25A), Glen Cove Road, and around the LIU Post campus. Whether you’re seeking a quick bite or a multi-course meal, these crossroads place you at the heart of Old Westbury’s culinary offerings.
- Glen Cove Road is the main artery, pulsing with diners, specialty shops, and casual takeout.
- Post Road/Northern Blvd is where you’ll spot food trucks and pop-up vendors, especially during school terms.
- Jericho Turnpike marks the path to upscale Italian spots and dessert shops just outside Old Westbury’s boundaries.
Closing Thoughts: A Taste for Every Appetite
Old Westbury may not be the most obvious foodie hotspot, but that’s what makes the discoveries here feel like your own delicious secret. Whether you’re craving fine dining, local comfort food, ethnic flavors, or something sweet, there’s a spot here with a menu and a smile waiting for you. So take a stroll, bring your appetite—and let Old Westbury surprise you!